Rubric

Keep in mind that 11 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
SciFi SS Rubric 1.0
SciFi SS Rubric 1.0
Criteria Ratings Pts
World-Building
threshold: pts
15 to >12.0 pts Exceeds Creates a rich, internally consistent world with thoughtfully developed rules, technology, and/or social structures
12 to >9.0 pts Mastery Establishes a coherent world with clear rules and convincing details
9 to >5.0 pts Near Presents basic world-building elements with some inconsistencies
5 to >0.0 pts Below World is poorly defined or contains major logical inconsistencies
0 pts No Evidence
pts
15 pts
--
Speculative Element Integration
threshold: pts
15 to >12.0 pts Exceeds Speculative elements (technology, society, etc.) are seamlessly woven into plot and character development
12 to >9.0 pts Mastery Speculative elements are well-integrated into the story with clear impact
9 to >5.0 pts Near Speculative elements are present but not fully integrated with the narrative
5 to >0.0 pts Below Speculative elements feel disconnected from the story or merely decorative
0 pts No Evidence
pts
15 pts
--
Extrapolation & Insight
threshold: pts
15 to >12.0 pts Exceeds Offers thought-provoking ideas about potential futures or alternative realities
12 to >9.0 pts Mastery Shows clear consideration of how changes might affect society or individuals
9 to >5.0 pts Near Contains some speculation about implications but with limited depth
5 to >0.0 pts Below Little evidence of thoughtful extrapolation from the central premise
0 pts No Evidence
pts
15 pts
--
Scientific Plausibility
threshold: pts
10 to >8.0 pts Exceeds Incorporates scientifically sound concepts or extrapolates from current knowledge in a convincing manner
8 to >6.0 pts Mastery Scientific elements are generally plausible with minor liberties
6 to >5.0 pts Near Contains some scientific elements but with significant liberties taken
5 to >0 pts Below Scientific concepts are implausible or used incorrectly
pts
10 pts
--
Plot Development
threshold: pts
10 to >8.0 pts Exceeds Story unfolds with compelling pacing, tension, and a satisfying resolution
8 to >6.0 pts Mastery Plot has clear direction with appropriate rising action and resolution
6 to >4.0 pts Near Basic plot structure present but with uneven pacing or weak resolution
4 to >0 pts Below Plot is confusing, meandering, or lacks meaningful resolution
pts
10 pts
--
Character Development
threshold: pts
5 pts Exceeds Characters have complex motivations, distinct personalities, and convincing arcs
4 pts Mastery Characters show clear motivation and some development through the story
3 pts Near Characters have basic traits but limited development or depth
2 pts Below Characters are flat, stereotypical, or inconsistent
pts
5 pts
--
Writing Style & Voice
threshold: pts
10 to >8.0 pts Exceeds Demonstrates distinctive voice with precise, evocative language
8 to >6.0 pts Mastery Clear, effective prose with consistent voice and good word choice
6 to >4.0 pts Near Basic competence in writing with occasional stylistic weaknesses
4 to >0 pts Below Significant issues with clarity, word choice, or consistency
pts
10 pts
--
Technical Accuracy & Editing
threshold: pts
15 to >12.0 pts Exceeds Virtually error-free with polished grammar, spelling, and formatting
12 to >9.0 pts Mastery Few errors that don't interfere with meaning or readability
9 to >5.0 pts Near Several noticeable errors that occasionally distract from the story
5 to >0 pts Below Numerous errors that significantly impact comprehension
pts
15 pts
--
Theme & Message
threshold: pts
5 pts Exceeds Explores profound themes or ethical questions with nuance and insight
4 pts Mastery Contains recognizable themes relevant to the story with some depth
3 pts Near Basic thematic elements present but underdeveloped
2 pts Below Lacks identifiable themes or meaningful exploration
pts
5 pts
--
Reader Engagement
threshold: pts
5 to >0 pts Engagement Story is memorable, thought-provoking, and emotionally resonant (0-5 points)
pts
5 pts
--